🏴‍☠️ ⚡️ Build Better ARR: Why Smart Operators No Longer Chase the Topline

Join us every Saturday morning for value creation playbooks, operating concepts, deal analysis and diligence frameworks, and more...

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

1. Why ARR is Under Pressure

2. First Principles: What Makes ARR Valuable?

3. The ARR Flavor Spectrum

4. Treat ARR Like an Asset Class

5. How to Flavor Grade Your Business

6. Metrics That Matter & Scorecards to Reinforce Quality

7. The Real Win—Upgrading Your Revenue Mix

---

📺 WATCH:

📻 LISTEN:

---

ARR isn’t dead—but our understanding of it should be.

In a market no longer rewarding growth-at-all-costs, operators, investors, and acquirers are waking up to the same truth:

Not all ARR is created equal.

We need to stop treating ARR like a monolithic number and start treating it like a portfolio. Each dollar of ARR carries its own risk profile, margin structure, and retention trajectory. Once you accept that, the strategy shifts.

This post is a blueprint for the modern operator who doesn’t just want more revenue—they want better revenue.

---

Why ARR Is Under Pressure

Before we talk about what makes ARR valuable, we have to acknowledge something more fundamental:

ARR is no longer universally understood—or universally relevant.

There’s a growing discrepancy in what ARR actually means. Operators and finance leaders increasingly debate:

• Is ARR contracted or implied?

• Should usage-based or outcome-tied revenue count?

• How do we measure ARR in the era of agents, AI models, or success-based pricing?

Modern SaaS—especially vertical and AI-native models—often monetize on usage, outputs, or dynamic pricing.

This makes classic ARR definitions blurry.

But instead of discarding, smart operators evolve.

They shift from treating ARR as a single KPI… to a portfolio of revenue assets, each with its own:

• Predictability

• Margin

• Retention dynamics

And with that lens, we can start making better decisions.

---

First Principles: What Makes ARR Valuable?

ARR quality is a function of three dimensions:

Topline ARR alone doesn’t tell you any of this. That’s why smart operators look deeper.

---

The ARR Flavor Spectrum

Let’s bucket ARR into four types—each with distinct traits:

Every operator should map their base to this grid. Where does your revenue actually live?

---

Treat ARR Like an Asset Class

Think of ARR like a portfolio. Some assets compound. Some bleed. Some should be sold off.

Stop managing ARR like it’s a single asset. Start optimizing your mix.

---

How to Flavor-Grade Your Business

Here’s a practical lens for evaluating the quality of revenue:

Use this lens quarterly—or whenever you’re making roadmap or GTM tradeoffs.

---

Metrics That Actually Matter

If you're operating in a niche vertical SaaS model—where pricing may be hybrid, month-to-month, or usage-based—how do you measure ARR performance accurately?

Implied ARR

Implied ARR = MRR (Trailing 12 Months Avg.) × 12

This provides a more stable, recurring run-rate approximation—but only if used responsibly.

⚠️ Use with Extreme Caution

You should only use Implied ARR if your logo retention is exceptional—ideally above 98%. Otherwise, this metric can dramatically overstate the quality and durability of your revenue.

Even with stellar retention, avoid using a single strong MRR month to annualize performance. This creates inflated expectations and can lead to:

• Overconfident budgeting

• Missed forecasts

• Mismatched hiring or expense plans

Always use a trailing 12-month average to account for volatility, seasonality, and one-off anomalies.

When used correctly, Implied ARR:

• Offers a credible growth narrative when contracts are informal or nonexistent

• Enables ARR-style forecasting and benchmarking

• Brings order to messy billing realities without misleading the business

💡 Translate operational complexity into strategic clarity—but don't mistake run-rate for guaranteed revenue.

---

Scorecards That Reinforce Quality

Great operators use scorecards to track revenue quality, not just size. Here’s what to monitor:

Category Metrics Growth New ARR, New Logos, Expansion vs. Base Retention Logo Retention %, NRR, Churned MRR Efficiency CAC, CAC Payback, Gross Margin Sales Productivity Funnel Conversion, Avg First Order Size Profitability EBITDA, Margin vs. Plan

EOS operators:

• These are your L10 scorecard essentials.

Quarterly investor update:

• Implied ARR growth

• Revenue mix by flavor type

• Expansion vs. churn balance

• % of new logos on annual contracts

---

The Real Win—Upgrading Your Revenue Mix

Growth still matters. But the real flex?

“We didn’t just grow revenue—we made it better.”

Better means:

• Higher-margin customers

• Longer retention

• More expansion

• Lower CAC

• Easier renewals

That’s the compounding power of flavor-shifted ARR.

Ask yourself:

• Are you measuring your ARR by size—or by flavor?

• Which asset class are you compounding?

• Where do you need to divest, upgrade, or reallocate your GTM effort?

This is how smart operators play the game now.

Not for growth-at-all-costs—but for durable, compounding value.

Start treating your revenue like an asset portfolio. Some dollars you protect. Some you grow. Some you reprice. Some you replace.

---

Hit REPLY and let me know what you found most useful this week (or rock the one-question survey below) — truly eager to hear from you…

And please forward this email to whoever might benefit (or use the link below) 🏴‍☠️ ⚡️

---